CDS Community Development Strategies
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Our Team >
      • Steve Spillette
      • Brenda Crenshaw
      • Michael Prats
      • Ty Jacobsen
      • Scott Reineking
    • Our Clients
    • Testimonials of our Work
    • Work with Us
  • Services
    • Market Analysis & Feasibility Studies
    • Economic & Demographic Analysis
    • Public Plans & Special Districts
    • Housing Studies
    • GIS Services
    • Surveys & Primary Research
  • Newsworthy
  • Lot Price Survey
  • Contact

Economic Optical Illusions

3/3/2017

Comments

 
J. Kirby Snideman
CDS Community Development Strategies

You might have seen this graphic passing around the internet this week. Are the strawberries below red or gray? It turns out they're actually gray. Read this article to find out why, and also for some insight into one big illusion that is often perpetuated in economic development circles--that job creation is always about the numbers. Companies often come into a community wanting incentives and promising jobs. But are the jobs they're promising worth the incentive?
Picture
First of all, in the previous image, you might still be convinced that you are seeing red... but I promise you, you're really seeing gray. You brain--similar to an automatic-color-balancer in a camera--is adjusting what you see because of the green tint. Your brain translates the green into white. In doing so, it also sees the gray as red. You don't have to know anything about strawberries for this to work. This is a feature of the ​human color perception system which ensures that the perceived color of objects remains relatively constant under varying illumination conditions. Another great example of this is the displayed in the image below. Squares A and B are actually the same color. But your brain compensates for the effect of the shade, making square A look darker.
Picture
Not unlike the optical illusions displayed above, we often see job growth figures tossed around that are boasting local, regional, or even national economic gains. But upon closer examination, we see that many of these jobs are often low wage--some very low. The chart below provides statistics on the ten largest occupations in the US in 2015. As can be seen, the average annual pay for eight out of ten occupations is below $30,000. Most of these occupations are associated with the retail industry.
Picture
This data from 2015 highlights a challenge that is often played out in small to medium sized cities all across America. Incentives are offered by these cities to attract businesses that are promising sales tax revenue and job growth. Each claim deserves serious scrutiny, particularly those associated with job growth. Part time jobs should be added up to count full time equivalent (FTE) jobs. While a typical big box retail store may have 200-300 part time jobs to cover various shifts, this often only adds up to 50 or less FTEs. And these retail focused jobs typically pay very little, often less than what is considered a living wage (a wage high enough to keep the wage earner out of poverty given the local cost of living requirements such as housing payments).

The bottom line is that while many businesses claim to be adding jobs to the local economy, relatively few add the more desirable high paying, permanent jobs. This is an important consideration that cannot be overlooked. While a local jurisdiction can liberally provide incentives to "grow at all costs," a more long-term, strategic approach will pay higher dividends. While enticing a small business of 20 employees may not look as good as adding a retail business with 200-300 jobs, that small business is the better investment (from the perspective of a local government that has limited incentive dollars to spend). Adding a handful of higher paying jobs that will allow employees to purchase a home in the area will have a profoundly more positive impact on the local economy than 200-300 part time jobs that will often not shift the economic indicators after closer examination. 

​About the author: 
Kirby Snideman is an AICP certified planning professional with a focus in economic development and currently serves as a senior associate at CDS.  Originally from Houston, Mr. Snideman has lived, studied, and worked in several places including Utah, New York, California, Iowa, Illinois, Oregon, and London, England.
Comments

    Follow CDS

    RSS Feed

    Search

    Categories

    All
    CDS In The Press
    CDS Projects
    Commercial Real Estate
    Cost Of Living
    Demographics
    Dense Development
    Employment
    Focus Groups
    GIS
    Grocery Stores
    Housing
    Housing Preferences
    Infrastructure
    Land Use
    LPS
    Market Analysis
    Market Trends
    Master Planned Communities
    Mixed Use
    Multifamily
    Municipal Utility Districts
    Office
    Parking
    Parks And Open Space
    Population Growth
    Race And Ethnicity
    Recreation Planning
    Redevelopment
    Rented Housing
    Research
    Residential
    Retail
    Rural Development
    School Districts
    Self-Storage
    Senior Housing
    Single Family Residential
    Small Towns
    Special Districts
    Student Housing
    Survey
    Taxing Policy
    Urban Planning
    Walkability

    Archives

    July 2021
    September 2019
    August 2019
    February 2018
    August 2017
    July 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    January 2014
    March 2013
    May 2011
    October 2010
    November 2009
    September 2009
    January 2009
    June 2007
    March 2007
    January 2007
    July 2006
    May 2006
    August 2001

© 2021 CDS - All rights reserved.  CDS is an InterDirect USA Ltd. company.
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Our Team >
      • Steve Spillette
      • Brenda Crenshaw
      • Michael Prats
      • Ty Jacobsen
      • Scott Reineking
    • Our Clients
    • Testimonials of our Work
    • Work with Us
  • Services
    • Market Analysis & Feasibility Studies
    • Economic & Demographic Analysis
    • Public Plans & Special Districts
    • Housing Studies
    • GIS Services
    • Surveys & Primary Research
  • Newsworthy
  • Lot Price Survey
  • Contact